When the player commits certain actions, the player will 'Sin'. There are two types of sin that are not clearly distinguished in-game. One type of sin generally pertains to making NPCs hostile, and absolving it is purely a means to undo that hostility (not affecting online invasions). The other type of sin pertains to the multiplayer aspect of the game, allowing members of the Blade of the Darkmoon covenant to invade those who have it in any online-area of the game. These two types of sin, their penalties, and their means for removal function independently.
The first kind of sin relates to angering NPCs. When a player attacks an NPC, they will have acquired sin. This can be absolved by requesting Absolution from Oswald of Carim, which serves as a way to make hostile NPCs and covenant leaders no longer angry at you. This type of sin is sometimes referred to by the community as "PvE" sin, because its effect on the multiplayer aspect is less significant.
This type of sin is not counted or accumulated in any way, as there is no difference to attacking one NPC or multiple. It is either "present" or "not present" for the player, which can be determined by finding out if Oswald will allow the player to pay for Absolution.
List of possible PvE Sins
- Anything that causes disapproval from an NPC or covenant, that requires Absolution to fix:
- Killing Gwynevere, Princess of Sunlight.
The only kind of PvE sin that cannot be removed is the kind that is obtained by destroying the illusion of Gwynevere. Although Oswald will allow the player to pay for its absolution, it will refresh and be placed upon the player again automatically.
Penalties for having PvE Sin
- There are no direct penalties in most cases. The player must have angered an NPC in order to have obtained this sin, in which case they may want to absolve. However, if the player isn't seeking anything from the affected NPCs, there is no negative result in ignoring them or killing them and leaving this sin intact.
- Players who obtain permanent PvE sin by destroying Gwynevere can now be invaded by members of the Blade of the Darkmoon covenant, but only in dark Anor Londo. This action will not affect or allow Darkmoon invasions in other areas.
This type of sin is counted and ranked in the Book of the Guilty. It cannot be absolved, but it can be removed by dying to a member of the Blade of the Darkmoon covenant, reducing 1 point of sin at a time.
List of possible PvP Sins
- Getting indicted by another player online.
- Getting kicked out of a covenant. This only applies to the following:
Penalties for having PvP Sin
- As long as the rest of the usual requirements for being invaded are met, players who are logged in the Book of the Guilty can be invaded by Darkmoons using the Blue Eye Orb. The Darkmoons hope to inflict justice for your guilt of sin, and they have the unique ability to invade players far below their own level.
- If the player is not risking invasions by not meeting the requirements, there are no other penalties or negative results to having this sin.
- Answering Alvina's questions, (also joining the covenant regardless of abandoning an existing covenant or not being in a covenant when doing it) counts as a sin (reasons unknown):
- Walking away without answering the first question will not result in a sin,
- Answering "Yes" to both questions and thus joining the covenant results in a sin,
- Answering "No" to Alvina's first quetion results in a sin,
- Answering "Yes" to the first question and "No" to the second one results in a sin as well.
- Leaving one covenant for another, even without the assistance of Oswald, does not trigger any kind of sin. PvP comes specifically from getting kicked out of any of the four covenants listed above, where the player's Covenant status switches to "none".